UNIT 8: DIFFERENT TYPES OF NATIONAL SERVICE IN VARIOUS SOCIETIES
Introduction
This unit eight talks about the different types of national services in some
countries like United Kingdom, in Israel, Ghana, Nigeria, Singapore, Brazil and
strong emphasis is made on Rwandan societies. It focuses also contributions
of the youth in the national service and general role of the national service in
national development.
National service is defined as an organised activity where people serve in the
community through different ways (according to the country and society), and
it has been adopted by different countries as solution to their internal problems.
It is one way to integrate the youth in national priorities and their contribution
into national social and economic development.
Many countries have adopted the national service for different purposes. Some
of them are inspired by the need of increasing the number of soldiers during the
war time. This is a case of national service in United Kingdom and in Singapore
for example. Other countries like Ghana, Nigeria and Brazil, the motives which
have guided option for national service including the need to incorporate the
youth into social and economic development of their countries.
In Rwanda, the adoption of national service was inspired by the concept of
volunteerism practiced in traditional Rwanda. Today, national service exists
under the term of Urugerero program. This is provided for in article 48 of the
Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda of 2003 revised in 2015. Through
Urugerero activities, they youth are trained and initiated to military trainings for
physical fitness. Thereafter, they are sent into their respective local communities
to help in implementation on some national policies like sensitization and
mobilisation against some diseases like malaria etc..
Key unit competence
Explain different types of national service in Rwanda and other countries.
Introductory activity
The youth, as adults, should contribute in social transformation of Rwanda towards
its Vision 2020 – 2050. How can national service be an easy way to help the Rwandans
to achieve this goal? Write 500 words text with pictures to illustrate your response.
Learning objectivesAt the end of this unit, I should be able to:
• Describe the concept of national service;
• Compare and contrast different types of national services;
• Assess the contribution of the youth in national service;
• Evaluate the role of the national service in nation building.
8.1 Definition of the concept of national service in Rwanda and other countries
Activity 8.1
By using internet and / or textbooks from your school library, define the concept
of national service in Rwanda
National service is a system of either compulsory or voluntary government service,
usually military service. This term of “national service” comes from the National
Service (Armed Forces) Act of 1939 enacted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom
on September 3, 1939. Through this service, many young people spent one or more
years performing national duties in the army or in civil service.
It can be also defined as an organized activity in which people serve the community
in ways that contribute to social, economic and political transformation at no
financial rewards.
In Rwanda, national service is known today as volunteerism and practiced through
Urugerero. The term volunteerism is defined by International Labour Organisation
as “unpaid,non-compulsory work, that is, the time individuals give without pay to
activities performed either through an organization directly forothers outside their
own household.” In Rwandan context, volunteerism is referred to as Ubwitange or
Ubukorerabushake, which literally means a“free will action”, performed out of selfmotivation and passion.
According to the adopted Itorero strategy, volunteerismis defined as “the
practice of people working for a particular cause without payment for their time
and services.It is the desire to under take by choice and free will a task or work
for the benefit of the wider community beyond the volunteer’s immediate family
and friends”.
Application activity 8.1
After understanding the concept of “national service”, reformulate your own definition.
8.2 Differences and similarities of different national serviceActivity 8.2
Through your research by using internet and other documents from your
school library discuss different forms of national service.
In many cases, the national services are in two forms, such as compulsory national
service and alternative civilian service.
8.2.1Compulsory national service
Compulsory national service (or military national service) typically requires
all male citizens to enrol for one or two years, usually at the age of 18 (later for
university level students). To large extent, compulsory military service is known as
conscription.
Conscription is compulsory enlistment of people in a national service, most often
a military service. Conscription dates back to Antiquity and continues in some
countries to the present day under various names. The modern system of nearuniversal national conscription for young men dates to the French Revolution in
the 1780s, where it became the basis of a very large and powerful military. Most
European nations later imitated the same system in peacetime so that men at
a certain age would serve from one up to eight years on active service and then
transfer to the reserve force.
Conscription usually involves individuals who are deemed fit for military service.
However, some governments have established universal military service in which all
men or all people of a certain age are conscripted.
Most governments use conscription at some time, usually when the voluntary
enlistment soldiers fails to meet military needs. Most of them only conscript
men; a few countries also conscript both men and women For example, China,
North Korea, Israel, Eritrea, Taiwan, Malaysia, Libya and Peru.
8.2.2 Alternative civilian service
It is a form of national service performed in lieu of conscription for various reasons,
such as conscientious objection, inadequate health or political reasons. It is service
to a government made by a civilian, particularly such service as an option for
conscripted persons who are conscientious objectors and to military service.
Civilian service is usually performed in the service of non-profit governmental
bodies or other institutions. For example, in Germany (before conscription was
abolished), those in civilian service worked extensively in healthcare facilities
and retirement homes, while other countries have a wider variety of possible
placements.
The common synonyms for the term are “alternative service”, civilian service, and
non – military service and substitute service as well.
Application activity 8.2
Compare and contrast different types of national service.
8.3 National service in Rwanda and in other countries
Activity 8.3
By using internet, textbooks, journals and newspapers, make a research on
national service in Rwanda. Then write down your findings in not more than 300
words.
8.3.1 Recent institutionalisation of national service in Rwanda
National Service - “Urugerero Programme” is provided for in Article 48 of the
Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda of 2003 revised in 2015. Urugerero
activities actually started on January 17, 2013 and it was officially launched in
Rwanda on January 22, 2013 in Rwamagana, Eastern Province by the then Right
Honourable Prime Minister Dr.Pierre Damien Habumuremyi. The National Itorero
Commission (NIC) organises various activities under Urugerero, whose outcomes
are paramount to national development.
Adoption of national service was inspired by the concept of
ubwitange(volunteerism) that was practiced by Rwandans in building the country.
This commitment led ancient Rwanda to great achievements such as the
expansion of the kingdom.
The Urugerero programme aims at developing programmes that enhance the
current efforts put in place to accelerate growth in all sectors of the economy by
adding a formalized voluntary service component.
The rationale of the volunteerism policy
• Educate Rwandans on the culture of volunteerism through activities of
national development;
• Provide a framework where people are able to make effective use of their
special skills and access unexploited potential which is an additional
contribution to national development;
• Build satisfaction among volunteers for their role in volunteer work for
increasing national production skills development associated with the
volunteering activities.
• Provide an appropriate institutional framework for effective management,
coordination and use of existingand future volunteer activities and resources.
• Provide a mechanism through which volunteer services can be recorded and
accorded national recognition.
Volunteerism in Rwandais currently exhibited through provision of services to the
community such as Umuganda,Ubudehe,Umusanzu (Communal self-help activities
based on solidarity), Abunzi,local government councils(Njyanama), Gacaca judges,
electoral commission agents, and community health workers (abajyanama
b’ubuzima)among others that do not involve any salary payment in return and
done out of free will for the purpose of benefiting the whole community.
The Government of Rwanda has adopted national service based on a combined
model (voluntaryandcompulsory). Initially, National service was compulsory for
the group between 18 and 35 years. People in that age category were officially
considered as part of the youth. Today, the youth age category is between 15 and
30. Other categories of the population will be allowed to participant on a voluntary
basis depending on their time,professional background and identified priorities.
The National Service programmes are based on national priorities that are
identified before the commencement of the service. Strategic choices namely vision,
goal, objectives to respond to the identified challenges are described to guide all
the programming processes of the Itorero programmes. A motto for the Urugero
has been proposed which states “Selfless service to the Nation”.
At the end of the service period, participants join together in their respective sites
to debrief on their experiences and lessons to inform planning for the following
intake. A closing ceremony is organized for them and during the ceremony; they
receive certificates of participation highlighting their contribution and experience
acquired in their placements. Exemplary participants are also recognised at this
ceremony.
There are voluntary interventions invarious sectors which the Government
of Rwanda has used volunteerism in such sectors like local governance,
justice,health and electoral processes. This Policy is aimed at providing
guidance on the management,rights, responsibilities and roles for both the
volunteer sand the volunteering organizations.
8.3.2 National service in other countries
Most countries have chosen the national service as an alternative way to involve
their population in nation building. The Countries which are described in this section
were chosen randomly; at least one country from each continent as an example.
National service in the United Kingdom (UK)
At the beginning in 1939, the national service enforced full conscription of all
males between 18 and 41 who were residents in the UK. It continued in a modified
form in peacetime by the National Service Act 1948. This Act of Parliament extended
the British conscription of the Second World War long after the wartime needs for it
had expired, in form of “National Service”.
The need for national service in the United Kingdom was inspired by the wartime
due to the need of more armed forces. The first phase of voluntary recruitment
was from 1916 to 1920 during the First World War and the second period from 1939
to 1960.
However, persons who were exempted from national service included the
following: medically unfit as well as the blind, disabled persons, and those with
mental disorders, British subjects from outside Britain who had lived in the
country for less than two years, students, persons employed by the government
of any country of the British Empire except the United Kingdom, clergy of any
denomination, married women, women who had one or more children 14 years old
or younger living with them, conscientious objectors, people working in reserved
occupations like baking, farming, medicine and engineering.
The National Service Act 1948 was applied to all healthy young men who were
not registered as conscientious objectors. It did not affect the exemption from
service of registered as conscientious objectors or the procedure for registration.
The period of serving in national service in the United Kingdom varied due to
national interest. By 1946, the period of national service was 6 months and this
period was increased to 12 months in 1949. From this time, men who completed
the service remained on the reserve list for the number of years in the age-range
(four years) which started being counted from the moment they finished serving.
However, men on the reserve list could only be called for periods of up to 20 days
(previous acts allowed the period to be indefinite), and could not be called more
than three times. In 1950, due to the British involvement in the Korean War, the
national service period was extended to two years. To compensate this long period,
the reserve period was reduced by six months.
In the United Kingdom, the national service was ended gradually from 1960. In
November 1960, the last men entered in service and the last national service men
left the armed forces in May 1963.
National service in Israel
In Israel, the national service is known under the conscription. This conscription
is for all Israeli citizens over the age of 18 years old who are Jewish and the
Arab citizens of Israel (Druze or Circassia) are not conscripted. The normal length
of compulsory service is two years and eight months for men (with some roles
requiring an additional four months of service), and two years for women.
The Israeli Defence Service Law regulates the duties and exceptions. According
to the Defence Service Law, the enlistment to the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) is
mandatory for all Israeli citizens who have turned 18 years old.
After the foundation of the State of Israel, the Defence Service Law passed in 1949
gave the Israeli Defence Forces the authority to enlist any citizen. Under this law, the
period of service for men was 30 months and for women 18 months (although in
accordance with a temporary order from January 10, 1968, six additional months
were added to the mandatory service, 36 months for men and 24 months for
women respectively).
The draft requirement applies to any citizen or permanent resident who has
reached the age of 18, and in accordance with the law, the individuals who are
exempt from the draft are dismissed for various reasons, such as incapability,
medical problems and military personnel needs. Exemption from military service
in Israel is given based on the following criteria: being expatiates, having medical
or psychological reasons, marriage, pregnancy or parenthood (for women only),
religious Israeli Druze citizens, Arab citizens of Israel and some young people are
exempted for holding a criminal record. Also, the security minister may exempt
certain people from an army service in the IDF, for reasons related to the volume of
the military forces or reserve forces, or for reasons related to educational needs,
settlement needs, security needs, economy needs, family needs and various other
reasons.
Furthermore, for those who cannot or do not wish to serve in the Israel Defence
Forces, there is an alternative voluntary civilian national service called Sherut Leumi. It
is a volunteer programme in Israel for young women between the ages of 18 and
21 years; though some men also participate, who cite religious reasons for opting
out of the requirement to serve in the Israel Defence Forces. It is also a popular
way for young Jewish volunteers from abroad to spend time in Israel. Volunteers
are matched with charitable organizations, like hospitals or orphanages, and live
together in a dorm-like setting. They serve for one to two years and are paid a
minimal salary.
National Service in Ghana
In Ghana, the national service is performed especially by the students who
graduate from accredited tertiary institutions. They are required to do a one year
national service in the country. The National Service Secretariat is the Government
of Ghana agency mandated to formulate policies and structures for national
service.
Every year, several tens of thousands of graduates from Ghanaian tertiary
institutions are posted to various sectors as service personnel. The service is done
irrespective of the type of sponsorship the individual may have received or the
country in which the tertiary course was pursued. The personnel upon posting to
an establishment is subjected to the rules and regulations that govern it. The service
personnel are paid monthly allowances approved by the Ministry of Finance in
Ghana.
All personnel are entitled to a month’s annual terminal leave for the year that spans
their service. The month leave is usually given in August to all personnel. The female
service personnel may apply for a three month maternity leave. When this leave is
granted, the personnel are to serve for three extra months to make up for the period
of service lost. The personnel who are granted maternity leaves are not paid during
the time of their leave.
The candidates for national service may on application be exempted from service
by the National Service Board on production of valid documentary evidence due to
the following conditions: an individual who has undertaken national service at an
earlier date and a graduate who is 40 years old or more.
By the end of national service, a service person shall be issued with a Certificate of
National Service after the successful completion of the service.
National Service in Nigeria
In Nigeria, the national service is known as the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC).
It is an organization set up by the Nigerian government to involve the country’s
graduates in the development of the country. The programme was started in the
aftermath of the Nigerian civil war, the Biafra War, in the 1970s. Particularly, there
is no military conscription, however, since 1973; the graduates of universities and
later polytechnics have been required to take part in the National Youth Service
Corps programme for one year.
The National Youth Service Corps in Nigeria aims at:
• Inculcating discipline in Nigerian youths by instilling in them a tradition of
industry at work, and of patriotic and loyal service to Nigeria in any situation
they may find themselves;
• Raising the moral tone of the Nigerian youths by giving them the
opportunity to learn about higher ideals of national achievement, social and
cultural improvement;
• Developing in the Nigerian youths the attitudes of mind, acquired through
shared experience and suitable training which will make them more
amenable to mobilization in the national interest;
• Enabling Nigerian youths acquire the spirit of self-reliance by encouraging
them to develop skills for self employment to contribute to the accelerated
growth of the national economy;
• Developing common ties among the Nigerian youths and promote national
unity and integration
• Removing prejudices, eliminating ignorance and confirm at first hand the
many similarities among Nigerians of all ethnic groups;
• Developing a sense of corporate existence and common destiny of the
people of Nigeria.
Nigerian graduates are ineligible for employment in governmental establishments
(and few private establishments) till they have completed the mandatory one
year service. Graduates who are exempted from the service include those above
the age of thirty (30) and those with physical disability. Therefore, completing the
service entitles one to employment.
The National Youth Service Corps’ members are posted to cities far from their
city of origin. They are expected to mix with people of other tribes, social and family
backgrounds, to learn the culture of the indigenes in the place they are posted to.
This action is aimed at bringing about unity in the country and to help youths
appreciate other ethnic groups. There is an “orientation” period of approximately
three weeks spent in a military controlled boot “camp” away from family and
friends. There, they are militarily trained and receive instruction according to their
studies in secondary schools. There is also a “passing out ceremony” at the end of
the year and primary assignment followed by one month of vacation.
National Service in Singapore
In Singapore, the National Serviceis a constitutional requirementfor all male
Singaporean citizens and second generation permanent residents to undergo a
period of compulsory service in the uniformed services. Depending on physical and
medical fitness, they serve a two year period as National Servicemen Full time,
either in the Singapore Armed Forces, Singapore Police Force or the Singapore
Civil Defence Force.
On March 14, 1967, the National Service (Amendment) Act was passed making
National Service compulsory for all 18 years old male Singapore citizens and
permanent residents. The establishment of National Service was a reaction to the
necessity to build a substantial military force to defend Singapore because, by the
independence, the country had only about 1,000 soldiers.
Singapore adopted a conscription model drawing on elements from the Israel and
Swiss national conscription schemes. Some 9,000 male youths became the first
batch of young men to be called up for National Service for establishment of the
Singapore armed forces. The period of National service is two years.
Complete national service exemptions are rare. It can be granted due to permanent
disabilities or severe medical conditions to be graded by Medical Board and other
exceptional case-by-case basis.
Those who are liable to serve national service as a national duty to the country but
refuse are charged under the Enlistment Act. If convicted, they face up to both
three years’ imprisonment and a fine of S$10,000 (equivalent to 8,550,000Rwf).
When a National Serviceman completes his full-time service, he is considered to be
“operationally ready”, and is thereafter known as an Operationally Ready National
Serviceman. In common parlance, the term “Reservist” is used, a vestige of the
older nomenclature preceding the current terminology. National Servicemen are
the equivalent of other countries’ reservists.
National Service in Brazil
National service in Brazil is known as Conscription and it is mandatory for every
male who has 18 – 45 years old and it normally lasts for twelve months. Some
are allowed six-month service terms but are expected to complete high school at
the same time. These are called “Tiros de Guerra,” or “shooting schools,” which are
for high school boys in medium-sized interior towns, run by army sergeants.
In case of a war, the period of conscription may be altered, according to the demands.
Seventeen-year-olds are allowed to undergo military service, as volunteers.
Conscription Brazil is regulated by the Military Service Law, created on August 17,
1964. Then, according to Article 143 of the 1988 constitution, military service is
obligatory for men, but conscientious objection is allowed. Women and clergymen
are exempted from compulsory military service.
The conscript system in Brazil is predominantly a means of providing basic military
training to a sizable group of young men who then return to civilian life and are
retained on the reserve rolls until age forty-five. The army recognizes that it provides
a public service by teaching large numbers of conscripts basic
kills that can be valuable to the overall economy when the young men return to
civilian life.
Application activities 8.3
1. Explain the contribution of volunteerism in Rwanda.
2. Compare the national service in Rwanda with those of Nigeria and
Israel.
3. What do you think are the objectives of volunteerism in Rwanda? Are
they achievable? Justify your answer.
8.4 The contribution of the youth in the national service
Activity 8.4
Write a short text explaining the role that must be played by the youth in the
In most countries, the youth represents the future of their countries; therefore, they
have a vital role to play in the development of each country through participating
in national service.
The training and participation of the youth contribute to the increase of national
army, where some become soldiers permanently or part time after accomplishing
military trainings.
The youth is the manpower provider because they participate in national service
by offering their physical force in order to accomplish national service goals like
construction of houses for the poor families, repairing the roads, construction of
vegetable gardens for family consumption. In environmental protection, the youth
in national service construct terraces and plant trees in order to fight against soil
erosion.
As earlier stated, in Rwanda, the youth at Urugerero have contributed in making
data collection. Most data collected were about the number of illiterate people in
their area of operations, the cases of school dropout and children of school going
age who are not yet in school, of local population who have not yet registered
for health insurance (mutuelle), number of family living in illegal marriage and
vulnerable groups.
Through Urugerero, the graduates of senior six secondary schools also perform
different national duties in line with the Government’s notion of self-reliance
and dignity. The most activities the students are engaged in include awareness
campaigns on development projects, HIV/AIDS, gender balance, family planning,
adult literacy and community work (Umuganda) among others. Furthermore, the
youth contribute in fighting and preventing people against the genocide and
genocide ideology, fighting against the drug abuse and sensitizing and mobilizing
local population about credit – saving through micro-finances like Umurenge SACCO.
The youth also contribute in national service by contributing in service provision
and delivery to local population at sector and cell levels. Services delivered
including distribution of official documents namely identity cards and land
registration certificates. Data entry in computers and customer care are also done
by national service participants. This boosts the service delivery to the local
population.
Application activities 8.4
1. Appreciate the contribution of the Rwandan youth in the national
service.
2. Discuss the benefits and challenges for the youth in carrying out
national service.
8.5 General roles of the national service in the nation building
Activity 8.5
Use internet and textbooks from your school library and carry out a research
about the contribution of Urugerero and volunteerism in the building of Rwanda.
In Rwanda, the National Service Urugerero programme aims at developing
programmes that enhance the current efforts put in place to accelerate growth in
all sectors of the economy by adding a formalized voluntary service component.
For instance, the participants have sensitized local population to join Mutuelle de
Santé, Umurenge SACCO and to participate actively in community service.
Through Urugerero, young people are supported to fulfil their potential and
to work together as a community. Each participant receives practical training
(training related to domains of service), training in civic education and basic military
training. This enables the participants to play a big role in economic and social
transformation of the country.
The national service increases solidarity among the Rwandan citizen as they are
initiated to help each other, strengthen national identity and reduces stereotypic
thinking by interfacing with the realities of the communities and the country in
general.
Through the military trainings provided to each participant, national service
promotes patriotism and civic participation especially among the young
generation.
By training the youth to fulfil national service activities, the country benefits from
the committed and motivated workers at no financial reward. The committed and
motivated workers often have a positive impact by influencing regular employee at
the work place hence contributing to the nation building.
Through the community service rendered to the local communities, national
service encourages social integration and cohesion necessary to national building.
In this regard, intore who are performing a range of activities are integrated in
those communities and have to work hand in hand with the local people who are
beneficiaries of such activities.
Participation in national service empowers those involved in different ways
including gaining new skills like leadership, problem solving, and interaction with
others among others. The participants are initiated to different tasks like planning,
design, building and other key roles throughout national service. Such practical
skills prepare them to contribute actively to the national building.
Participating in a national service programme offers members a unique
opportunity to develop personally and professionally. Research has proven
that those who participate in service increase their understanding of how they
can address social challenges. Being a national service member also provides
opportunities for enhanced problem solving skills, ability to work in teams and
planning abilities.
For people with disabilities, engaging in national service provides an additional
opportunity; to shift perceptions and show that people with disabilities can be
service providers, not just recipients of service.
In Rwanda, the volunteerism has contributed a lot to national development
where, in 2011 for instance, the volunteerism has contributed more than 30 % to the
national Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Due to the work performed by community
health workers, local government officials and committees, election process
managers, mediators (abunzi), judges in Gacaca courts and Rwanda Red Cross, the
Government of Rwanda has saved about 70 billion Rwf.
In Rwanda, the national service is a continuation of the spirit of promoting positive
values among Rwandans, especially the youth. The values of unity, patriotism,
selflessness, integrity, responsibility, volunteerism, humility enhanced during the
national service contribute to the promotion of nation building.
National service encourages young people to enter careers in fields experiencing
shortages: In education for instance where the national service persons help in
adults teaching. To explore future job and educational interests can be motivation
to join national service for the young people and their career plans become more
community oriented.
Application activities 8.4
1. By considering your local area, evaluate the role of Urugerero
accomplished by senior six leavers in social transformation of Rwanda.
2. Appreciate the contribution of volunteers in rebuilding of Rwanda
since 1994.
End Unit Assessment
1. Describe the organization of Urugerero as national service in Rwanda.
2. Compare national service in different countries. Choose one country per
continent.
3. Explain the contributions of abunzi, mediators, and judges in Gacaca
courts, community health workers and election process managers in
national building of Rwanda.
4. Evaluate the role of the youth during Urugerero
GLOSSARY
Compulsory: That must be done because of the law or rule.Which is required,
obligatory or mandatory.
Peacetime: The period of time when a nation, a country or people is in peace,
not fighting a war.
Wartime: The period during which a country is fighting a war. A period during
which a war is in progress in a particular place.
Motto: A short sentence or phrase that expresses the aims and beliefs of a
person, a group, an institution or a nation, etc. and is used as a rule of behaviour.
Debrief: To ask someone questions about a job they have just done or an
experience they have just hard, in order to gather information. To question
someone after a military mission in order to obtain intelligence.
Intake: The number of people who are allowed to enter a school, college,
profession, etc. during a particular period.
Exemption: Official permission not to do something or pay something that you
would normally have to do or pay.
Enlistment: A voluntary service based on an individuals’ desire to serve a cause.
Amenable: Easy to control; willing to be influenced by somebody / something.